This is this: The Jussie Smollett case: Hoax or not, Chicago Police have some explaining to do

After 14 months, Neftali Reyes Sr. and Annette Flores are still waiting for justice for the murder of their son while the police waste resources on celebrity investigations

bobA column by Bob Chiarito.  2/17/19

For more than two weeks the public has read and watched news reports about the search for two men who attacked actor Jussie Smollett in the wee hours of the morning on January 29. As the search by police went on, a growing chorus of people started to question what seemed obvious from the start, but mostly off-the-record. 

If you have been out of the country, the story from Smollett is that on January 29 he was walking from a downtown Subway restaurant around 2 a.m. when two men hurled racial and homophobic slurs at him, told him “this is MAGA country” and beat him, then threw an undetermined chemical substance on him and looped a rope around his neck before running off, all while he was on the phone with his manager, who confirmed what they said.

I’m not going to debate whether or not Smollett is telling the truth. As I write this it seems the police are finally admitting what I’m sure the rank and file officers knew from the beginning — that it was bunk. When they come out and say that, there will be people calling for Smollett to be charged with making a false report and he should be. He should also have to reimburse the City of Chicago for money spent investigating his claims. The City in turn will shift the blame to Smollett, but they should have to explain why so much manpower was dedicated to this case in the first place, hoax or not. 

Twelve detectives worked on the Smollett case. A dozen. For a guy who didn’t even have to go to a hospital. What about the investigations of real crimes that are unsolved? Let’s assume for the sake of argument that Smollett is telling the truth. It’s a horrible hate crime that should be investigated and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, no doubt about it. But the police department assigned 12 detectives to it. In a city with a homicide clearance rate under 20 percent. In fact, in 2017 it was 17.5 percent and in 2018 it declined to under 16 percent. That means 84 percent of the killers in Chicago are still on the loose. That also means 84 percent of the families whose loved one was murdered have not gotten any closure or justice. 

Like Annette Flores and Neftali Reyes Sr. Their son, Neftali Reyes Jr., was killed while driving in West Town on December 29, 2017 and since then there have been no arrests, no closure and no justice.


Neftali Reyes Jr.


Reyes Jr. was a star baseball player who grew up in his parents neighborhood of Humboldt Park. After graduating with honors at Roberto Clemente Community Academy High School, where he also was a star pitcher and third baseman, Reyes Jr. attended Claflin University in South Carolina on a full baseball scholarship. During his freshman year, he injured his shoulder and underwent Tommy John surgery. He was back home for winter break and was leaning towards going down to the Dominican Republic to play for a team that feeds the Major Leagues when his dream was stolen by a bullet. 

On that December morning, a black Hyundai Sante Fe rammed the back of his Chevrolet several times, causing it to crash into a parked Mercedes. The Hyundai pulled up, and someone fired shots at Reyes Jr.’s car. Two bullets didn’t go through the car door, but one did and went into his chest. Two hours later he was pronounced dead.

Before their son was killed, Reyes Sr. and Flores were already familiar with gun violence. Both grew up in Humboldt Park where they raised their son and his younger sisters and both were victims of gun violence themselves. When Reyes Sr. was 17, he was shot 6 times and when Flores was 14, she was shot in the head twice in a drive-by. Both lived, unlike their son who was killed by a single bullet. That’s how unfair things can be, like how a tornado can rip down a street destroying some homes while others are left completely untouched. Three shots were fired at Reyes Jr.’s car that December day, but one struck him and killed him.

I met with Reyes Jr.’s parents –Annette Flores, a 38-year-old homeaker and Neftali Reyes Sr., a 40-year-old union carpenter, at a cafe in Humboldt Park. We were about two blocks from their home and less than a mile from where their son was murdered. We talked about the Smollett case, the lack of respect the police have for regular citizens, but mostly we talked about their son.

Flores has been active in the media and with victim’s groups in order to keep the pressure on the police. She reserved judgement on whether or not Smollett was assaulted, but is upset about the police attention it has garnered.

“They are very selective to what cases they want to give more exposure and attentiveness to. I think it’s definitely an injustice what happened to Smollett. Nevertheless, he’s still breathing and he’s still walking. Yet, there are so many detectives and attentiveness to that specific case when a case like my son’s, there’s just a lack of regard,” Flores said.


Flores and Reyes Sr. with their son on his graduation day from Roberto Clemente High School


Since her son’s murder, the police hardly ever update her and Reyes Sr. 

“This is the way it works and it happens so much, it’s unreal. They really don’t reach out. The horrible part is that when my son was shot, the detective assigned really dropped the ball. He did not obtain imperative evidence. It was almost like, ‘Another gunshot victim, oh well.’ Then you have a celebrity or someone that they feel is important and immediately the cameras work. My son was chased for two miles. I canvassed the area myself with my family and found every business that had a camera. If you’re really taking regard to the situation, you’re going to backtrack to obtain very important information, which was not done. We are constantly reaching out, there are no updates. We get ignored for weeks and months at a time,” Flores said. “It causes sadness in you. It causes anger. You’re so frustrated, doing their work for them. I’m out here not only trying to deal with this loss, but also — and you should do your own investigation because it’s your child – but when you’re assisting the police as much as we have…it’s so unfair.”

Reyes Sr. agreed, saying the detectives on his son’s case are lazy. 

“Detectives are not doing detective work. They wait for things to fall into their lap. They wait for people to come forward out of the blue. They had a video of the car behind my son’s car. If they would backtrack more, they may have the guys going into a gas station or something before that and see their faces clearly,” Reyes Sr. said. “The Mayor’s son was robbed, remember that? They found that guy within a month.”


Neftali Reyes Jr. as a young boy


Flores said that she isn’t sure if her son was mistaken for someone else or if the offender was jealous of him, but she believes the low homicide clearance rate adds to the city’s violence problem because the shooters feel that they can get away with it. 

“Mistaken identity? I’ve tried so hard to ask them questions like that. My son grew up in this area, he died blocks from home. Envy is definitely a possibility, “ Flores said. “I do believe that these gangbangers target you if you have a friend or a family member that’s the opposite of them and they don’t care. These young boys are dying in the city. The shooters are so comfortable getting away with these murders and they feel like, ‘You don’t have the right t-shirt on, I’m going to shoot you and kill you and I’m going to get away with it.’ All these guys that have no goals, no direction and no life have no regard for life. The problem is that they are so accustomed to getting away with it.”

Flores also said her son’s goodness may have increased her vulnerability and said perhaps his father should have warned him of the danger.

“Part of me feels like his father should have taught him to be ready for something like that. But because he was not part of that life, he wasn’t a street boy, he didn’t have a worry that something like that would happen to him,” Flores said.

Reyes Sr. said had the shooter or shooters known his son, he would still be alive today because of the love people had for him. He added that when his son died, there were so many people at the service that some people weren’t able to get in to pay their respects.

“He was so loved everywhere he went. If his killers knew him and spent a couple days with him, they would have liked that kid. That’s how big of a heart he had. He was a role model who encouraged younger kids,” Reyes Sr. said.

Both Flores and Reyes Sr. said although nothing will ever bring their son back, it is vital that his killer answer for his crime, and in a testament to her character, Flores added that perhaps the person could change their life around.

“There will be accountability. I’m not God and it’s not my duty to seek vengeance. It’s accountability and justice,” Flores said. “Maybe in jail when they are sentenced to whatever they get, I pray that they have a change of heart. Maybe they will change their life. Save another soul.”

Reyes Sr. echoed Flores, saying “My son didn’t deserve that, obviously, and there is nothing we can do to get him back. Whoever did it was wrong, dead wrong. For my son not to be here and these guys are running the streets, they don’t deserve to be out here. They took a good kid, they took a good soul.”

Flores also said her son’s killer may have been a victim himself at some point.

“There’s a lot of these kids out here, you don’t know their background. You don’t know what turned them into that animal. Sometimes it’s nothing and they are just horrible human beings. Sometimes it’s hurt. Hurt people hurt other people, that’s an epidemic as well. But when justice prevails more than injustice and when you have convictions happening, there is accountability. And some would think twice.”

In another example of how well regarded Reyes Jr. was, after he was killed Clemente High School dedicated its home baseball dugout to him with a plaque that contains his picture and a description of his character, proclaiming the dugout “Neff’s Dugout.”

Additionally, the Chicago Cubs sent a letter to the family because it was Reyes’ Jr. who was selected as the neighborhood ambassador when Little Cubs Field in Humboldt Park was dedicated in 2008 — despite the fact that Reyes Jr. was raised a White Sox fan.

“I raised him right,” Reyes Sr. said, laughing. 

Flores also laughed while recalling the letter.

“It said something like anytime a Cub fan is lost we lose someone. Little did they know, he was a White Sox fan!”

The family paused after recalling that story and their laughter turned back to silence. Unfortunately, the laughs remain few and far between for Flores and and Reyes Sr. as they wait for the Chicago Police Department to focus on their son’s unsolved murder.

Flores summed up the feeling best, as only the mother of a slain child could. Calling the lack of convictions and arrests an epidemic and a slap in the face, she said “My son was a good kid. He was making it. How dare you just disregard him. How dare you do it to any child. How dare you.”


Be sure to “Like” us on Facebook!

Follow us on Twitter!

3 Responses to “This is this: The Jussie Smollett case: Hoax or not, Chicago Police have some explaining to do”

  1. Wilfredo Santiago

    I too am a parent of a murdered son and his name was Wilfredo Santiago Jr. My son was visiting his cousin on Francisco Ave while getting off the bus, three individuals rush upon my son with one arm with a gun, fired and struck him several time. He was reviled but later succumbed to his injuries. My son murder was never solved and no closure for me and my family. He was murdered on Sept tenth, 2015 just a few days after his birthday September first. I just wanted to express my deepest sympathy to all gun violence families all over this country.

  2. Aramis Ayala

    Whether it was a hoax or not, it drew attention to racism. That’s what matters.

    • Bob Chiarito

      Nonsense. By falsely blaming his “attack” on homophobic Trump supporters, Smollett hurt every real victim of racist or homophobic attacks.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

%d bloggers like this: